“To sign a document means to authenticate that which stands for or is intended to represent the name of the person who is to authenticate” (quoted in the case below)

We all know that verbal agreements, although fully binding for most types of transaction, are a recipe for uncertainty and dispute. It’s not just a question of trust – even if no one is deliberately dishonest about what was agreed, innocent misunderstandings are common. We have a natural tendency to hear what we want to hear and to remember what we want to remember, and a properly-drawn written agreement avoids that.

So even when a written and signed document isn’t required it is always wise to insist on one. Note that the parties themselves can require a document to be in writing and signed. Or it could be required by law – the most common examples of the latter are property sale agreements, wills, suretyship agreements, ante-nuptial contracts, and credit agreements (there are other less common examples – take professional advice in doubt).

But that’s not always easy to achieve, and the COVID-19 lockdown in particular has highlighted the challenges of getting everyone together for an old-fashioned original “paper and ink” signing session. Even when social distancing is no longer required and ceases to be the norm in society, the convenience and benefits of being able to sign documents remotely (whether you and the other party/ies are in different houses, cities, countries or even different continents) are obvious.

Firstly, when is a digital agreement “in writing”; and can property sales and wills be electronic?

Fortunately our law, in the form of the ECTA (Electronic Communications and Transactions Act) recognises the general validity of digital documents. A “document or information” is “in writing” if it is –

  • “In the form of a data message; and
  • Accessible in a manner usable for subsequent reference.” 

As a result, perfectly valid and enforceable agreements are now often entered into online, by email, WhatsApp and the like. 

Note that there are some specific exceptions where a physical (“wet ink on paper”) as opposed to an electronic format is still required – most commonly property sale agreements, “long” (10 or more years) leases and wills (there are others – take advice in doubt).

Secondly, is “signature” always required?

Formal “signature” isn’t always essential as the ECTA provides that if the parties to an electronic transaction don’t specifically require an electronic signature, “an expression of intent or other statement is not without legal force and effect merely on the grounds that –

  • It is in the form of a data message; or
  • It is not evidenced by an electronic signature but is evidenced by other means from which such person’s intent or other statement can be inferred.”

Thirdly, how can you sign a document electronically?

Where “signature” is required, the ECTA recognises the concept of “electronic signatures” (defined as “data attached to, incorporated in, or logically associated with other data and which is intended by the user to serve as a signature”. They are valid except in cases where either a law (like the laws relating to property sales etc mentioned above) or the parties themselves require actual physical signatures.

An electronic signature can take many forms. Where it is required by the parties but they haven’t agreed on a particular type of electronic signature to be used, it is valid if –

  • “A method is used to identify the person and to indicate the person’s approval of the information communicated; and 
  • Having regard to all the relevant circumstances at the time the method was used, the method was as reliable as was appropriate for the purposes for which the information was communicated.”

That definition will often be wide enough to include names on email messages, scanned images of physical signatures and the like. But remember the parties can specify what formats are and aren’t allowed, plus our courts may well look at all the circumstances of a case and decide for example that an actual manuscript signature is required even when transmitted electronically (see for example the “R804k” judgment discussed below).

“Advanced” electronic signatures

This is a concept of authentication designed to make an electronic signature more reliable and it is used when a law requires signature for specified documents or transactions but doesn’t require another particular type of signature.  

For example the Deeds Registries Act requires documents like the Power of Attorney to Transfer Property to be signed, and that can be done either physically or electronically – but if electronically the electronic signature must be an advanced one. The Credit Agreements Act provides other good examples. 

Even when not specifically required, a big advantage of advanced electronic signatures is that they are presumed to be valid. That means anyone attacking one would have to prove its invalidity and not the other way round.

Security and fraud; with an R804k example

Cyber criminals are as always waiting to pounce so all the normal warnings in regard to electronic communication apply here, with the added need to ensure that electronic documents cannot be altered after completion/signature. 

A recent example of “forged electronic signatures” is an online fraud that went horribly wrong for a firm of financial advisers who were sued for R804,000 when their client’s Gmail account was hacked by fraudsters – 

  • Using the investor’s authentic email credentials, the fraudsters sent three emails to the financial advisers instructing them to transfer a total of R804,000 to the fraudster’s accounts. Two of the emails ended with the words: ‘Regards, Nick’ while the third ended with ‘Thanks, Nick’.
  • The financial advisers made the transfers and the investor sued them on the grounds that they had paid out contrary to the written mandate he had given them which stipulated that ‘All instructions must be sent by fax to [011 *** ****} or by email to [***@***.co.za] with client’s signature.’
  • The financial advisors argued that they had complied with the mandate in that the email endings “Regards, Nick” and “Thanks, Nick” were valid electronic signatures in terms of ECTA.
  • The SCA (Supreme Court of Appeal) however upheld the High Court’s ruling that the financial advisors were liable. They had not complied with the mandate which “requires a ‘signature’ which in every day and commercial context serves an authentication and verification purpose … The word ‘electronic’ is conspicuously absent from the mandate …  The court below cannot be faulted for concluding that what was required was a signature in the ordinary course, namely in manuscript form, even if transmitted electronically, for purposes of authentication and verification.”

Play it safe – have your lawyer draw and manage your agreements for you to minimise this sort of risk, and ask also about using an external service provider for secure, authenticated and verifiable electronic document signing and storage. If you do come to blows with the other party down the line, the integrity and evidential value of your electronic documents and signatures could be make-or-break.

 

INCREASE IN TRANSFER DUTY EXEMPTION THRESHOLD MAKES IT EASIER FOR FIRST-TIME HOMEOWNERS

Transfer duty, the money payable to SARS on the purchase price of the property gets determined...

NSRI’S WATER-SAFETY TIPS

It’s always tempting to take the plunge when temperatures soar and you’re in the holiday spirit....

Safe banking over the festive season

The South African Banking Risk Information Centre (SABRIC), on behalf of the banking industry,...

Reflecting on the Year 2020

The year is beginning to wind down pretty quickly and most of us are trying to fit in as much as...

HOUSING PRICES SPIKE INTO DOUBLE DIGITS

  During South Africa's lockdown, the average house price went into a rapid decline, with...

LANDLORDS AND TENANTS: Know Your Rights

This year, many stressed South Africans have been forced to tighten their belts yet another...

POPIA – THE SUMMARY

PROTECTION OF PERSONAL INFORMATION ACT (Also known as POPIA) Why do we need the Protection of...

Rent Versus Salary - What South Africans can afford accommodation?

Even before the global pandemic, South Africa was in dire a dire economic situation. Acting as a...

DECEASED ESTATE PROPERTY TRANSFERS

During a person’s lifetime, he/she will accumulate assets as well as liabilities. The assets can...

THE IMPORTANCE OF HAVING A WILL

    Most people do not know whether their loved ones have executed a Will, where...

PROS AND CONS OF EACH TYPE OF PROPERTY OWNERSHIP

Though many might not be aware of it, there are three different forms of homeownership in South...

EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW BEFORE HOUSE HUNTING

With more affordable property prices and bank approval rates at historically high levels, coupled...

FAQ's When Buying or Selling a Property

Q: To whom do I pay the deposit? A: The Purchaser’s deposit can be paid either to the estate...

CERTIFICATES OF COMPLIANCE

If you are selling your property, then you are going to most certainly need a number of...

PROPERTY PRICING - WHY AND HOW TO GET IT RIGHT

When it comes to putting a property on the market,  some sellers believe listing the property...

MY TENANT WANTS TO BUY, CAN THE RENTAL AGENT CLAIM COMMISION?

With the interest rate at a low 7%, tenants are finding that it might be cheaper to purchase...

HOW MANY CONVEYANCERS DOES IT TAKE TO TRANSFER A PROPERTY?

Buying or selling a property for the first time is a milestone event in any person's life....

DIVORCE & ACCRUAL – LIVING ANNUITIES AN ASSET IN THE ESTATE

In the case of CM v EM it was held in the Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa...

BUILDING VS HOME CONTENTS INSURANCE KNOW EXACTLY WHAT YOUR INSURANCE COVERS

It appears that many South Africans took the opportunity to do renovations at their homes, during...

HOW TO FAST TRACK THE PURCHASE OF YOUR PROPERTY

Purchasing a property is a big decision, one in which the buyer will have...

THE IMPORTANCE OF A LIVING WILL 

What is a living will? A living will is a document that lets people state their wishes...

SOUTH AFRICAN WOMEN'S DAY

Have you ever wondered why we celebrate Women’s Day on the 9th August in South Africa? It has...

DOES YOUR HOME OFFICE QUALIFY YOU FOR A TAX DEDUCTION?

Does your home office qualify you for a tax deduction? As the old adage goes, change is as good...

HOLD ON TO YOUR STATUS AS A HOMEOWNER

Clients in financial difficulties in these tough times can get to keep their homes, provided they...

THE PANDEMIC AND BUSINESS INTERRUPTION COVER, CAN YOU CLAIM?

  “…it must be asked whether, but for the Covid-19 outbreak, the interruption or...

THE MEDIA MAY BE CALLING IT AN "ACT OF GOD", BUT WHAT DOES THE LAW SAY ABOUT FORCE MAJEURE AND COVID-19?

When disaster strikes it is easy for the world to fall into disarray. The impact of natural...

A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A CONVEYANCER DURING THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC!

A DAY IN THE LIFE OF A CONVEYANCER DURING THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC! Armed with comfortable shoes,...

Electronic Signatures in Property and Other Transactions

“To sign a document means to authenticate that which stands for or is intended to represent the...

POPI COMES INTO FULL EFFECT ON 1 JULY ARE YOU READY?

Protection of Personal Information Act “POPI” Comes into full effect on 1 July 2020 Are you...

QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER DURING THE REPORTING OF AN ESTATE

Questions to consider during the reporting of an estate   How do I report an estate to the...

ALL YOUR PROPERTY QUESTIONS ANSWERED!

All your property questions answered!   Experts answer your questions on property matters...

NO FFC - NO COMMISSION NOT ALWAYS THE CASE?

NO FFC – NO COMMISSION NOT ALWAYS THE CASE?   Estate agents are not entitled to earn...

LANDLORDS MUST 'GET REAL' ABOUT PROPERTY PRICE EXPECTATIONS

Article By Bonny Fourie Property 360 / 7 June 2020 Property is only a sound investment if you...

BUYER'S MARKET LIKELY TO LAST

Article courtesy of Property 360:  25 May 2020 No rush if you want to buy – market will go...

4 SMART THINGS YOU CAN DO RIGHT NOW TO SAVE MONEY DURING SA’S DEEP COVID-19 RECESSION

South Africa was headed for a recession way before Covid-19 turned everything upside down. As a...

PROPERTY SELLERS – PREPARE FOR SPLUMA

Many factors can delay your property transfer, and all of them are likely to cost you.  A...

WHAT ARE YOUR RIGHTS WHEN IT COMES TO FORCED COVID-19 TESTING?

As the COVID-19 pandemic is spreading across the globe, Minister of Health, Zweli Mkhize has...

How to make a will and get it witnessed

Locked down during the pandemic: How to make a will and get it witnessed The last few weeks have...

IS YOUR HOUSE IN ORDER?

Getting your house in order involves big things, such as having life insurance and a valid will,...

WHAT HAPPENS TO THE SIGNED ANTENUPTIAL IF YOUR WEDDING CEREMONY IS POSTPONED DUE TO COVID-19

The Covid-19 pandemic and the national lockdown that was implemented in order to contain the...

Arrested under the Disaster Management Act?

Arrested under the Disaster Management Act? You have the right to challenge it! Admission of...

The risks of dying without a will (Albeit not a valid one)!

Although we are in lockdown and may be working for home, many of us have a bit more time on our...

DO TENANTS STILL HAVE TO PAY RENT DURING LOCKDOWN?

 Following please find answers to the pertinent questions regarding the payment of rent...

TIPS FOR INVESTING IN PROPERTY FOR RETIREMENT

Have you ever wondered if real estate is a sound investment? Well, it certainly can be! There are...

FAQ’S FOR DIVORCES

HOW LONG DOES THE DIVORCE PROCESS TAKE? A divorce action can be finalised within one month or it...

NEW RULES FOR WHO GETS THE KIDS THIS WEEKEND

Who gets the kids this weekend? Following please find new regulations around the movement of...

WESTERN CAPE RENTAL CONSIDERATIONS

In recent times the Western Cape has become the area to stay in. With the spectacular sea view or...

CONTACT OUR PAARL OFFICE

Email: paarl@nsvattorneys.com
Tel: +27 (0)21-870-1185
Address:
 138 Main Road, Paarl, WC 7646

CONTACT OUR TYGERVALLEY OFFICE

Email: info@nsvattorneys.com
Tel: +27 (0)21 914 4481
Address: 
5 Ground Floor, Bateleur Office Park, Pasita Road, Tygervalley